← All insights

The gap between stated and revealed preferences

The study looked at secondary school enrolment in rural Rajasthan, at the transition from upper primary to secondary (classes 8 to 9), where girls' dropout rates remain highest. Rajasthan's UDISE data consistently show strong enrolment at upper primary level and a sharp fall at secondary. The pattern has persisted despite large investment in infrastructure, conditional cash transfers under the Mukhyamantri Rajshree Yojana, and state-level campaigns on girls' education.

The study asked parents why, starting with a survey. The survey gave a clear and largely positive picture. The overwhelming majority of surveyed parents in all three study blocks said they supported their daughters continuing to secondary school. Most said they intended their daughters to complete class 12 and preferably go on to higher education, and very few cited financial cost as a barrier. In what parents said, support for girls' education was close to universal.

The enrolment data did not match. Actual dropout rates at the class 8-9 transition in the same blocks were between 28% and 35% depending on the block, consistent with the state pattern. The gap between what parents said they intended and what the enrolment records showed was large.

Focus groups showed where the gap came from. Conversation in a group moved differently from a household survey. Parents followed individual statements such as "I want my daughter to study" with accounts of how those preferences played out in practice, and especially of what happened when an individual preference met community expectations.

Most parents probably did hold the preferences they stated in the survey. Collective norm enforcement in the community was overriding them. Secondary schooling in these blocks usually meant a school that could not be reached on foot, in most cases 5 to 12 kilometres from home. Getting there took a bus or another vehicle, crossed areas without continuous social supervision, and put girls in mixed-gender public spaces for the whole journey. In communities where a girl's safety and a family's reputation are understood to be tightly linked, the household does not make the decision to send a daughter on that journey every day by itself. The extended family and the immediate community evaluate it and, in some cases, sanction it.

Families who sent daughters to secondary school anyway described an informal cost: monitoring, commentary and, in some cases, active pressure to stop. Several families withdrew their daughters with no single incident behind it, after sustained social friction had made the decision impossible to keep up. Others had expected this cost and never enrolled their daughters in the first place.

An individual-level survey has trouble detecting this mechanism. A household survey that asks about preferences and barriers treats the household as the unit of decision-making. In communities with strong norm enforcement the decision is made in a social field that extends beyond the household, and neither the preferences nor the constraints sit with the individual alone.

For programme design, this means investment in schools, buses and hostels is necessary but not sufficient. Parents in these communities want their daughters to attend secondary school. The binding constraint is that they cannot hold to that decision against community pressure without social cover. Interventions that have worked in similar contexts provided that cover, either by making the norm-deviant decision more common, which reduces any one family's exposure, or by creating community forums where parents who want their daughters to continue could state and reinforce that preference together.

The Rajasthan finding is not new. Duflo (2012) and later work on social norms and female education document similar patterns in other places. For research methods, it shows that eliciting preferences where decisions are embedded in a community needs instruments that pick up the collective side of individual decisions.

UDISE+ Rajasthan district data on enrolment, dropout, and school location. ASER 2022 for state-level learning outcome context. Mukhyamantri Rajshree Yojana administrative data from the Rajasthan Directorate of Women Empowerment.